R. v. Bland: Police Pacing Evidence
Citation: R. v. Bland, 1974 CanLII 809 (ON CA). Ontario Court of Appeal, December 20, 1974. Result: the appeal was dismissed.
What Evidence Was Considered?
The prosecution relied on police speedometer evidence. The appeal also raised the absence of oral evidence about the applicable speed limit. The court considered the evidence and the regulation setting the limit on the particular road.
The Court’s Reasoning
A speedometer reading over the relevant distance could provide prima facie evidence of speed in the absence of evidence suggesting inaccuracy. The regulated limit could be judicially noticed in the circumstances. Those findings supported the conviction.
The Practical Limit
Prima facie evidence does not remove the prosecution’s ultimate burden of proving the offence beyond a reasonable doubt. Nor does this decision mean that the applicable limit never needs to be established in another case. Different roads, legal limits and evidence require their own assessment.
Use the pacing guide to understand the method and disclosure to examine the actual observations. Later discussion in Iagolnik explains why historical decisions should not become a rigid checklist. Return to the Ontario speeding ticket case-law index for related issues.
Get Advice About Your Speeding Ticket
Pacing evidence needs review against the observations and records in your file. A licensed paralegal can assess whether the decision is relevant and how the prosecution’s actual evidence should be addressed.