R. v. Lounsbury: Why the Timing of Radar Tests Mattered
R. v. Lounsbury is a Manitoba speeding decision about whether the evidence connected radar testing to the time of the alleged offence. It is a useful historical comparison, but it is not binding Ontario appellate authority.
Citation: R. v. Lounsbury, 1993 CanLII 14956 (MB QB). Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench, October 21, 1993. Result: the appeal was allowed and the speeding conviction was quashed.
A Test Was Recorded, but When Was It Done?
The radar operator initially described checks before and after issuing the offence notice. Under cross-examination, he acknowledged that he did not independently remember the tests and was describing his usual practice. His notes recorded testing but did not establish how many checks had been performed or when.
The appeal court could infer that the radar had been tested at some point during the shift. It could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the device was working properly at the relevant time. The conviction was quashed and the charge dismissed. The important distinction was between evidence of a general routine and evidence sufficiently linked to this particular measurement.
The Testing-Evidence Problem
The officer described usual testing practice and notes indicating some testing, but the timing of the checks was unclear. The court found that the evidence did not establish beyond a reasonable doubt that the unit was working properly when the alleged offence occurred.
Why Its Jurisdiction Matters
This is a Manitoba decision, not binding Ontario appellate authority. It should not be presented as an Ontario rule that usual-practice evidence can never be considered. The governing legislation, later decisions and the complete record matter.
The issue was discussed in Durham v. Zhu, alongside other authorities. Later Ontario discussion in Iagolnik also warns against applying older speed-measurement cases as a universal checklist.
How It Can Inform a Review
The useful question is what the actual evidence establishes about the particular unit and event. Request the relevant disclosure and identify the gap you say affects reliability. The radar guide explains the method, while the Ontario speeding ticket case-law index places this historical decision alongside other results.
R. v. Lounsbury: Frequently Asked Questions
Was Lounsbury an Ontario speeding decision?
No. It was a Manitoba appeal. Its reasoning can be read as a historical comparison, but it should not be labelled an Ontario Court of Appeal ruling.
What changed when the officer was cross-examined?
The officer initially described testing before and after issuing the offence notice. Under cross-examination, he acknowledged that he did not independently remember performing those tests and was describing his usual practice.
Did the officer have any note of radar testing?
Yes. The notes indicated a test or tests, but the record did not establish how many checks had been performed or when they occurred. The problem was not a complete absence of any reference to testing.
Why did the time of the radar checks matter?
The court could infer that testing happened at some point during the shift, but could not connect it sufficiently to the time the driver’s speed was measured. It was not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the device was working properly at that relevant time.
Did the court decide that tests immediately before and after every stop are always required?
The court discussed the possibility that a test immediately before or immediately after use could suffice in some situations, but did not decide that issue. In this case the timing was unknown; it allowed the appeal, quashed the conviction and dismissed the charge.
Get Advice About Your Speeding Ticket
This is a Manitoba decision, so its role in an Ontario case needs careful assessment. A licensed paralegal can evaluate its relevance alongside Ontario authorities and the evidence in the current file.